Kitchenware Rater is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Best Knife For Pumpkin Carving

Find a Good Pumpkin Knife

When it comes to carving pumpkins, it is hard to find a quality knife for this job. Most of the pumpkin carving knives are filled with cheap, dull tools that will break within a few uses. Locating a quality pumpkin cutting knife isn’t the easiest because most knives are not explicitly made for pumpkin carving.

In a rush? Is it getting close to Halloween? No problem, just skip the details and check out our top three knives for carving pumpkins here.

With that being said, there are a number of characteristics that make a knife good for cutting the hollow, round shape of a pumpkin. The best knives for cutting pumpkins are going to be knives with small to mid-range blade length (3”-7”) with sharp or even jagged edges.

To go one step further, we took it amongst ourselves to find the best knife for carving pumpkins. In this review, we break down which knives are the best for this job, and what characteristics make these knives the best.

Related: What is a Slicing Knife used for?

Best Pumpkin Knife for Jack-o’-lanterns

Precise German Engineered Paring Knife

  1. Mercer Culinary Genesis Forged Paring Knife, 3.5 Inch
Pumpkin Knife

Key Features :

  • Includes one 3.5” High Carbon Steel Paring Knife
  • Versatile knife for pumpkins and much more
  • Made from high carbon forged German steel
  • Santoprene handle for comfort and safe grip
  • Taper-ground edge makes for easy cutting, sawing, and long-lasting sharpness
  • Rust and cooperation resistant

Meet the Mercer Culinary Genesis Forged Paring Knife with 3.5” blade. This knife is a perfect option for those who are looking to add a knife to their collection that can easily handle the demands of carving pumpkins.

This paring knife is perfect for the job because the short, sharp blade is the perfect size to glide through the pumpkin surface to easily shape perfect designs. Also, it’s perfectly maneuverable for cutting some intricate shapes on your Jack-o’-lantern.

Made from German high carbon forged steel, this blade is guaranteed to resist rust, staining, and discoloration. This blade meets high standards when it comes to sharpness, quality, and longevity.

The full tang included on the knife ensures that this knife will feel comfortable in your hand while using. Although it is ideal for carving pumpkins, this knife will likely be your tool of choice for a number of jobs around the kitchen, as its size and sharpness make it quite dynamic.

The Mercer Culinary Genesis Forged Paring Knife is the perfect option for those who are looking for a knife that can carve pumpkins and more. Coming in at under $20, this knife is easily the best value when looking for the best pumpkin knife.

We think this Mercer blade is the best knife for pumpkin carving.

Check Today’s Price at for the Mercer German Knife

Professional Carving Knife/Saw with Blue Steel Serrated Blade

2. Keyfit Professional Pumpkin Carving Knife

Pumpkin Knife

Key Features :

  • Includes one 6.5” Pumpkin Carving Knife
  • Sturdy construction built to last
  • Professional-grade blue-hardened 6.5” Steel Blade
  • Ultra-sharp saw-style teeth are perfect for cutting pumpkins
  • Ergonomic 6” handle

In the running for best pumpkin knife is the Keyfit Tools Professional Pumpkin Carving Knife. This premium pumpkin carving knife features a 6.5” steel blade with ultra-sharp saw-style edges. This jagged edge makes carving patterns and designs effortless.

With blue-hardened steel, the blade on this knife is built to last and remain sharp use after use. Considering the quality of this blade, this knife will also be useful for cutting and slicing other fruits, vegetables, and meats.

The 6” ergonomically-friendly handle makes each cut comfortable and safe. Overall, this pumping carving knife checks all the boxes when you’re looking for a quality, sharp pumpkin carving knife.

Check Todays Price at for the Blue Steel Serrated Blade


When it comes to finding the best and most useful knife to use when carving pumpkins, it is important to have a quality blade that is not too long.

The best knives for carving pumpkins don’t have to be especially made for pumpkins, but instead could be a high quality paring knife like the one listed above.


Can you use a regular knife to carve a pumpkin?

It’s not recommended to use a regular kitchen knife to carve a pumpkin. There are simply better and safer tools for the Job.

As with cutting almost anything, the sharper the knife the better. There’s nothing worse than having to hack around with a dull blade and you’ll end up with poorly carved pumpkin.

How long will a carved pumpkin last?

It really depends on the climate that you live in. In warmer areas, carved pumpkins may last up to a week whereas, in colder climates, they can last a fortnight.

Do I need a pumpkin carving knife?

It depends. I know that makes me sound like a lawyer but it’s true. With carving anything, safety should be the number 1 priority.

An excellent paring knife will work beautifully with a pumpkin. If you already have one, you are all set. If you don’t have one, the Mercer above is our favorite paring knife, period. Not just for pumpkins.

Which is the ideal knife for carving pumpkins?

We think the Mercer German Carbon Steel paring knife above is the best knife for pumpkins. See above.

How do you ensure safety when using a carving knife for a pumpkin?

Do not be in a rush! Take your time.

Work a well-lit space, on a sturdy surface, with your knife in a clean, dry hand. Never reach inside a pumpkin while you are cutting it – with either hand.

Adults are the best choice to be pumpkin carvers. Never allow a child to carve a pumpkin without adult supervision.

How do you start carving a pumpkin?

Now that you have the right knife to carve your pumpkin, you should know how to start carving. The best way to do it is to start from the bottom and then remove the seeds by scooping them in circular motions.

Can vinegar help preserve your pumpkin?

To keep you pumpkin fresh, bush the outside with two tablespoons of white vinegar and a teaspoon of lemon juice mixed with a quart of water. Also use some petroleum jelly to preserve the interior and the curved parts. It prevents drying out and ensures the pumpkin stays in shape.

Leave a Comment