Best Baking Pan for Chicken 2020

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Best Baking Pan for Chicken

Cooking dinner at home has never been more essential than now, but not having the proper cookware can be frustrating.

Especially when cooking chicken, having a quality baking pan that is large enough to handle a lot of foods is key.

There are a few main characteristics that your baking pan must have to ensure that it is suited to handle such a challenge.

In a hurry? Here are our top product choices for the best baking pan for chicken.

Check Todays Price On Amazon Below

1-Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Roast Pan with Non-Stick Rack,

2-Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan / Roaster with Rack

3-Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Stainless 16-Inch Rectangular Roaster with Rack

For starters, roasting chicken at home calls for two things:

A roast pan and a rack for the meat to sit on above the fats, oils, and other liquids that will be in the bottom of the pan.

Size and shape of the roast pan is important, as it must be big enough to hold a whole chicken for hours of cooking without warping or bending.

Common issues that occur when cooking with lower quality baking pans for chicken can be imperfect cooking (undercooked, overcooked, unevenly cooked), 

high rising oils/fats at the bottom of the pan interfering with cooking food, and the pans/racks condition will not hold up against the test of time.

Lower quality pans will also “pop”, bend, and warp under too much heat or weight.

To combat these issues, our featured products are all high-quality baking pans that have been proven to perform exceptionally when cooking chicken.

In addition, the following featured items also meet expectations when it comes to longevity, as each have proven themselves against the test of time.

Check Todays Price On Amazon Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Roast Pan with Non-Stick Rack

Our first baking pan recommended for cooking chicken is the Chicago Metallic professional non-stick roast pan and rack.

Pan dimensions – 13in x 9in with 2.25 in. walls. 

This pan makes our list because of the value it offers as a reliable everyday roast pan that can also specialize in cooking chicken.

Coming in just a bit smaller than the rest of the pans on our list, the roast pan and rack by Chicago Metallic is well-built and bound to exceed expectations.

Simplicity is key with the Chicago Metallic roast pan. With an easy-fit rack that sits at the perfect height above cooking oils and juices, roasting chicken has never been easier.

This pan was made with heavyweight aluminized steel, giving it a respectable cooking surface that will deliver even, reliable cooking throughout your chicken.

When it comes time to clean up, the silicone-based pan makes it easy work to erase oils and other cooking grime from your pan, leaving it looking new for your next use.

Those who reviewed the Chicago Metallic roast pan and rack were surprised at what they got in return for such an affordable buy.

Many buyers were impressed by the lifespan of the non-stick surface as it remained easy to clean even after months and months of use.


  • Covers the basics with flying colors

This pan won’t be the most flashy piece in your set, but it truly does the trick when roasting chicken.

The Chicago Metallic roast pan and rack are made from high grade aluminized steel that will stand up to the test of time.

Add on the fact that cleanup is easy with the non-stick technology, and this is a fantastic overall baking pan for chicken.

  • Price

Coming in at under $20, there is no denying that this is one of the best deals you will find on a reliable baking pan.

Considering this incentivized price point, along with the ability to fulfill all of the basic baking pan needs, the Chicago Metallic professional roasting pan had to kick off our list of best baking pans for chicken.


  • Chicken is this pan’s size limit

While this pan is quite the value for money, buyers will have to sacrifice just a smidge of size when purchasing this pan.

The chicken will easily be cooked in this pan, but larger meats such as turkey or big portions of prime rib may present a challenge.

  • 450 Degree cap

Those who like to cook with the broil method beware, as this baking pan has a temperature cap at 450 degrees.

While this is more than enough heat to cook most foods, it should be noted that broiling and other intensely high heat methods could warp the shape of this Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Roast Pan.

Check Todays Price On Amazon Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan / Roaster with Rack

Our second featured roasting pan for chicken is the Circulon nonstick roasting pan/roaster with rack. Pan dimensions – 17in x 13in with 3.5 in. walls.

This Circulon product is a step above your beginner roasting pan and rack.

Made from high-grade gauge steel that ensures the distribution of heat evenly throughout the cooking process, this pan is proven to be a quality cooking surface that will roast evenly.

Non-stick technology makes sure that your baking pan will be spotless for your next use. 

The standout feature of this pan is the U-rack and the difference that it makes to your cooked food, especially chicken.

The U-shape of the food rack allows for your chicken to cook right above those juices and oils, getting your chicken as juicy as possible.

The U-rack is equipped with easy-grab handles that allow for quick and simple maneuvering of your rack and anything on it.

When the rack isn’t needed, simply remove and use the pan for any other deep dish needs.

Circulon had a very good argument for being number one on our list because of the vast amount of positive reviewers of this pan.

Satisfied users of this pan love the easy cleanup, with one reviewer stating their amazement of how easily burnt juices were rinsed from the surface.

The unique U-rack shape is also a popular review topic, as many love the snug fit that the U-rack takes within the roasting pan.


  • Ideally build for the user

When using the Circulon roasting pan, it is obvious that the user’s experience was taken into heavy consideration.

The handles on the rack are farther above and away from the pan than most other competitors, allowing for a comfortable grip.

The rack fits perfectly in the pan and is easy to maneuver. There are countless small positives about this pan, making it one of our absolute favorites.

  • U-Rack promotes even roasting

The unique U-rack design from Circulon makes this pan absolutely ideal for roasting chicken.

Conventionally flat roasting surfaces often roasts the bottom of the chicken slightly more than the top.

The shape of the U-rack is able to minimize this cooking difference, allowing the chicken to roast more evenly.

  • Circulon consistency

As one of the most established kitchen brands in the world, Circulon has continued to churn out high-quality cookware, and this piece is no different.

Circulon products deliver a consistency that is hard to find, making their roasting pan one of our featured baking pans for chicken.


  • Hand-wash recommended

The quality of this baking pan won’t stick around for too long if it is excessively cleaned in the dishwasher.

While one or two cleans in the dishwasher might not hurt, it is not recommended that this pan or rack be cleaned by this method because of the constant heat and water exposure.

Check Todays Price On AmazonCuisinart Chef’s Classic Stainless 16-Inch Rectangular Roaster with Rack

Rounding out our list of the best baking pans for chicken is a roaster and rack made by Cuisinart. Pan dimensions – 12.8 in. x 16.8in with 3.4 in walls.

This roast pan and rack can do it all in the kitchen.

There is no questioning the cooking performance or quality of this pan, as it is capable of meeting all of our previously mentioned standards.

With all of the basics checked off, this product goes above and beyond what can be delivered by your usual baking pan.

There are small details that set the Cuisinart roaster and rack above the pack.

The stainless steel design is one huge standout feature that allows this product to excel where others couldn’t.

For example, the stainless steel construction makes the baking pan and the rack easy to clean, ruling out the need for a non-stick coating that can eventually wear thin or chip off.

This roasting pan is also dishwasher safe, and will not rust like most other pans like it.

In addition, this stainless steel baking pan can handle temperatures above 450 degrees and allows for drip-free pours of juices and oils due to smooth sides; Two details that other competitors’ roast pans cannot claim.

Reviewers loved the stainless steel appearance of the Cuisinart roaster and rack, as the sleek silver look is much more appealing than the standard coated appearance that most roasting pans have.

Countless satisfied buyers reported their approval of the size of this roast pan and how many different foods it can accommodate.


  • Outperforms expectations

While this pan is ideal for cooking chicken and middle-range sized meats, it has proven itself with larger tasks.

This cooking pan by Cuisinart has proven itself to the delight of many happy reviewers, who’ve reported that 20+ lb turkeys, 15+ prime rib, and other large meat challenges have been tackled by this quality baking pan.

  • Stainless steel makes cleanup a breeze

Unlike the majority of baking pans that are coated in non-stick formulas, Cuisinart’s pan is made from high grade stainless steel.

The stainless steel pan will hold up over time, while the pan that’s been coated will eventually start to become harder to clean as that coating wears thin.

  • Professional quality for fraction of the cost

One massive reason that forced this product to number one on our list was the price for value.

With professional-grade performance and appearance at just a fraction of the cost of the same size pans made by the most expensive kitchen brands, Cuisinart’s classic stainless 16-inch roaster pan is a must-have when looking for the best baking pan for chicken.


  • Can be heavy with meats/juices

The high grade stainless steel that is used on the pan and rack gives this product a nice, quality feel, but this weight can get to noticeably heavy levels in certain circumstances (i.e. when cooking with large meats or large amounts of liquid in the pan).

Review: Best Baking Pans for Chicken

Remember that all baking pans aren’t created equal, and finding the right baking pan for chicken comes down to a few key points. When finding the perfect baking pan for chicken, make sure to consider :

  • Quality

With dozens of imitators out there, you’ve got to find the high quality pans that will be able to handle the size and weight of a chicken.

  • Cooking performance

Of course, the cooking performance must be considered when finding the best baking pan for chicken. Each baking pan on our list is guaranteed to be made with high grade steel, ensuring a reliable and even cook on your chicken.

  • Longevity

There is no point in putting money into a baking pan that will have to be replaced in 5-6 months time. Our best baking pans were selected with longevity in mind, as each selection is well-equipped to last years and years of proper use and wash.

Check Todays Price On Amazon Below

Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan / Roaster with Rack

Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Roast Pan with Non-Stick Rack,

Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Stainless 16-Inch Rectangular Roaster with Rack

Leave a Comment